Stocks vs mutual funds: Which is better and in which field?

Stock vs mutual funds: Which is better and in which field? it’s a tough part to decide has which is the best or better. Whether you spend in mutual funds or stocks it depends on 3 constituents.

  • First, one must determine how much risk you can bear versus how much return you need or demand. If one needs a higher return, they must accept greater risk.
  • Secondly depends on how much time you have to examine investments. That involves how much one enjoys studying financial statements or fund schemes.
  • The third factor is what type of charges and expenses you are ready to endure. If you intend to purchase and hold, you don’t need annual fees. You’ve additionally taken to examine the tax implications.

Now let us discuss the 12 elements on which we can differentiate the stock vs mutual funds.

1.Investment Range or limits

In stocks, one can receive quick and higher returns if one selects the right stocks. Plus, further, sell them at the right time and place.

When investing in mutual funds, recognise that one will have to give the funds at limited 5-7 years to produce great returns. As these have a longer-term growth track.

2.Diversification of stock vs mutual funds

The great-diversified portfolio should continue at limited 25 to 30 stocks but that will be a huge call for a small investor.
With mutual funds, investors with little funds can also get a diversified portfolio. Getting units of a fund enables one to invest in various stocks without having to invest a large entity.

3.Return and Risk

It is already confirmed that mutual funds have the benefit of decreasing the risk by changing a portfolio.
Stocks, on the other side, are helpless to the market conditions. Plus the performance of 1 stock can’t repay for the other.

4.Tax Profits- stock vs mutual funds

When investing in stocks, one will be responsible to pay 15 % tax on your short-term capital gains. If one market one’s stocks in one year.

In mutual funds, there is no tax on capital gains on the stocks that are traded by the fund. This can involve real benefits for investors. The tax saved is more convenient for one to invest it further. So making space for additional income generation through investment. Although one will have to endure on to their equity for more than 1 year. In line to avoid paying short-term capital profits tax.

Direct investment in shares can provide you tax advantages only under Section 80CCG
Mutual funds can be alleged under Section 80C if it is an ELSS(Equity-Linked Savings Scheme).

5.The time difference in receiving returns – stock vs mutual funds

When one spends directly, he/she will require to invest much more time and analysis into their stock.
In the case of mutual funds, one can be influenced. The fund manager is the person who spends his time to maintain one’s portfolio.

6. Stocks and Mutual Funds: Understanding

When linked on a risk factor.
stocks appear to be notably riskier than mutual funds. The risk in mutual funds is reached beyond. Hence decreased with the pooling in of different stocks.
With stock, one has great research before investing, Particularly if one is a beginner investor.
In the case of mutual funds, the analysis is done and the fund is administered by a mutual fund manager. This service though is not free. Begins with an annual management price that is imposed by the fund house.

7. Buying and selling – Trading

The selling and buying of stocks can take spot at any time throughout the day including intra-day dealing at the current price.
Whereas in mutual funds, they traded simply once a day seemingly at the end of the regular basis on which the NAV all is settled.

8.Cost determination

The particular share value of the stock is calculated by the no. of shares determining the cost of stock held by the investor.
The cost of a mutual fund can be calculated by appearing at the NAV which is the complete value of assets net of expenses.

9.Ownership

Stocks signify ownership stake to the investors.
Mutual Funds renders partial ownership to the all over a basket of bonds and securities.

10. SIP (Systematic Investment Plan) plan and investments- stock vs mutual funds

The SIP investments are more applicable in mutual funds. One can invest in mutual funds by a fixed monthly SIP, as it is operated by a professional.
Stocks cannot perform such a fixed investment in shares directly as the rates vary regularly and require special attention and quick trade judgment.

11. Tracing investment made by individual

With an investment in mutual funds, one has the advantage of a fund manager who has great expertise and knowledge in the field. Whether it is determining the stocks or controlling them and getting allocations. One does not have to bother regarding any of it.
This service is not possible in the state of stock investments. One is responsible for selecting and tracing their investment.

12. Exit system

In Stocks, most individuals do not know when to exit. But in mutual funds, a person is aware when to entry and exit of stocks managed because of the financial advisor’s advice.

All of the above is the difference between a stock and mutual funds which investors must understand to decide whether which is best amongst them.

Stocks vs Mutual Funds – Who renders Better Returns

To analyse and compare the best returns from stocks and mutual funds. We have chosen the returns formed by the top mutual funds and Stocks in India in the form of tables.

A table for mutual funds returns

Name of the fund3-Year Return (%)5-Year Return (%) 10-Year Return (%)
 ICICI Prudential Bluechip Fund10.97 17.0615.88
SBI Magnum Multicap12.6221.1212.77
HDFC Hybrid Equity Fund 5.92 15.65 11.77
NIFTY 500 11.27 16.53 12.39
Mirae Asset Emerging Bluechip Fund16.8630.29      –
Kotak Standard Multicap Fund12.7620.97      –

While watching at the returns created by these funds, we can see that the maximum of these funds has overcome the NIFTY Index for the given time durations i.e. 3-year, 5-year, and 10-year returns.

A table for Stock returns

Stock Name3-Year Return (%)5-Year Return (%)10-Year Return (%)
HDFC Bank Ltd. 25.8725.7626.26
Hindustan Unilever22.1322.8822.88
Infosys9.6915.8911.84
Ultratech Cement9.5415.2420.95
Maruti Suzuki 30.2341.7829.91
Sun Pharma 12.752.2015.43

However, measuring the returns of the top companies in the NIFTY Index, we see the following above.

Stock vs Mutual Funds: Comparative Table

Basis of differenceStocksMutual funds
Meaning Mass of shares held by an investor showing ownership in a Corporation The fund managed by an AMC. It’s collecting in money from investors and investing in a portfolio of assets.
 Ownership Shares of a CompanyShares of a Fund
 Management Investor Fund Manager
 Trading During the day at the current priceOnly once usually at the end of the day
 Risk HighComparatively low due to professional management
 Final Investment Straight in the stock market In the fund, investment is directed.
 Cost Determination  Cost of share on the exchange NAV -Net Asset Value
 Share/ CommissionPaid when a stock is exchanged These can be in the kind of load or no-load. The percentage can be paid either at entry or exit or in both the conditions.

Notes: AMC is Asset Management Company

Conclusion

While making an investment in Stocks or Mutual fund is entirely an individual decision. One should understand the merits and demerits connected with each of the avenues. Both of these titles are fitting in for small-scale investors with limited investments. Though stocks give the possibility of directly investing in the stock market. One necessitates holding a regular track of the performance to determine the future course of action. The risk and profits are fully owned by the investor.
Mutual funds give the rest of diversification in the basket. In summation, these funds are run by professionals within the ambit of strategies assigned. So the investors can be comforted of continuous monitoring of the investment. The benefits of mutual funds are more than stocks.

For knowing more about the Mutual Funds Investment. Sig into our website WealthBucket. We provide a platform in which one can get wide range services of Large Cap mutual fundMulti-Cap mutual fundSmall Cap Mutual FundsShort Term Mutual Funds or Income Funds

One can give us a call at +91 9999379929. You can also email, in case of any problems about investing in mutual funds at contact@wealthbucket.in.

Related Articles

Mutual fund tips

Best mutual fund to invest

How a Mutual Funds Calculator works

By |2019-08-08T07:40:49+00:00May 27th, 2019|mutual funds|0 Comments

About the Author:

This article has been posted by Pulkit Jain - the founder of WealthBucket - To raise awareness about Mutual Funds Investments. WealthBucket has made investing in Mutual Funds an easy, quick and welcome process, in India. An interactive online platform providing Trustworthy and sincere services to all its clients.